Cap Rates Explained: What a Capitalization Rate Means for Commercial Property Value
Updated October 2026 · Written by Matthew Reynolds, MAI
Quick answer
A capitalization rate (cap rate) is a property’s annual net operating income (NOI) divided by its value or sale price. A building earning $100,000 a year in NOI that sells for $1,600,000 has a 6.25% cap rate. Appraisers use cap rates from comparable sales to turn a property’s income into a market value: Value = NOI ÷ Cap rate. Lower cap rates mean higher values and usually lower perceived risk.
In this guide:
- What is a cap rate?
- How to calculate a cap rate
- What counts as net operating income
- How appraisers use cap rates
- What moves cap rates up or down
- Common mistakes
- FAQ
What is a cap rate?
A cap rate expresses the relationship between what a commercial property earns and what it is worth. It is the unleveraged annual return an all-cash buyer would earn in the first year, before any loan payments. Investors, lenders and appraisers use it to compare properties of different sizes and prices on equal terms.
Cap rates are a market measure. They come from what buyers have actually paid for similar properties, not from a formula an appraiser chooses. That is why the same cap rate cannot be applied everywhere: a new single-tenant pharmacy in Carlsbad and an older multi-tenant strip center in a smaller market trade at very different rates.
How to calculate a cap rate
The formula has three versions, depending on which number you are solving for:
| To find | Formula | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Cap rate | NOI ÷ Sale price | $100,000 ÷ $1,600,000 = 6.25% |
| Value | NOI ÷ Cap rate | $100,000 ÷ 6.25% = $1,600,000 |
| NOI | Value × Cap rate | $1,600,000 × 6.25% = $100,000 |
Small changes in the cap rate move value a lot. On the same $100,000 of NOI, a 6.0% cap rate implies about $1,667,000 and a 6.5% cap rate implies about $1,538,000, a difference of roughly $128,000.
What counts as net operating income
NOI is the property’s income after operating expenses, but before debt service, income taxes and depreciation. Getting NOI right matters as much as choosing the cap rate.
- Start with potential gross income: all rent at current lease rates, plus expense reimbursements and other income such as parking.
- Subtract vacancy and collection loss: a market-supported allowance, even if the building is full today.
- Subtract operating expenses: property taxes, insurance, utilities, repairs, management and reserves for replacement, unless tenants pay them under the leases.
- Leave out: mortgage payments, depreciation, income taxes and one-time capital projects.
The NOI behind a sale’s cap rate and the NOI of the property being appraised must be measured the same way. If the comparable sales’ cap rates were based on in-place rent before reserves, the subject’s NOI should be too.
How appraisers use cap rates
In the income approach, an appraiser estimates a stabilized NOI for the property and divides it by a cap rate drawn from the market. This method is called direct capitalization. The appraiser supports the cap rate with:
- Comparable sales: recent sales of similar properties where the price and income are known.
- Investor surveys: published surveys of the returns buyers are seeking for each property type.
- Band of investment: a cross-check based on current loan terms and the return equity investors expect.
For properties with income that will change significantly, such as a building in lease-up or with major leases expiring, appraisers often use a discounted cash flow analysis instead of, or alongside, a single cap rate. For date-of-death and retrospective appraisals, the cap rate must reflect the market on the effective date, not today.
What moves cap rates up or down
| Factor | Tends to lower the cap rate (higher value) | Tends to raise the cap rate (lower value) |
|---|---|---|
| Tenant | National, creditworthy tenant | Local or unrated tenant |
| Lease term | Long term remaining with rent increases | Short term or near expiration |
| Contract rent vs. market rent | Below-market contract rents with upside when leases roll to market | Above-market contract rents at risk of rolling down at lease expiration |
| Location | Strong, supply-constrained market | Weaker or oversupplied market |
| Property | Newer, well-maintained, flexible | Older, deferred maintenance, special-purpose |
| Interest rates | Falling borrowing costs | Rising borrowing costs |
Property type matters too. Apartments and industrial buildings have generally traded at lower cap rates than suburban office or small strip retail, because investors see their income as more reliable. Ranges change with the market, so an appraisal relies on current sales rather than rules of thumb.
Common mistakes
- Using a seller’s pro forma NOI: projected rents applied to a market cap rate overstate value.
- Not applying a vacancy and collection loss factor: capitalizing 100% occupancy overstates NOI and value; even a fully leased building should carry a market-supported vacancy allowance.
- Mixing NOI definitions: comparing a sale’s cap rate before reserves with a subject NOI after reserves.
- Applying a national average: cap rates vary by city, submarket, tenant and lease.
- Ignoring contract vs. market rent: a below-market lease with ten years left is worth less than the same building leased at market, and above-market rent that will roll down at expiration should not be capitalized as if it lasts forever.
- Confusing cap rate with cash-on-cash return: cap rate ignores financing; cash-on-cash return includes it.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good cap rate for commercial property?
There is no single good cap rate. A lower cap rate means a higher price relative to income and usually lower risk; a higher cap rate means more income per dollar but usually more risk. The right rate for a property comes from recent sales of similar properties in the same market.
Is a higher cap rate better?
For a buyer, a higher cap rate means more first-year income per dollar invested, but it usually signals more risk, such as a weaker tenant, shorter lease or less desirable location. For a seller, a lower cap rate means a higher price.
Does the cap rate include the mortgage?
No. A cap rate is calculated before debt service, so it is the same whether a buyer pays cash or borrows. Returns after financing are measured with cash-on-cash return or internal rate of return.
How do appraisers choose a cap rate?
Appraisers derive cap rates from comparable sales where both price and income are known, then cross-check them with investor surveys and the band-of-investment method. The final rate reflects the subject property’s tenant, lease, location and condition.
What is the difference between a cap rate and NOI?
NOI is a dollar amount: the property’s annual income after operating expenses. The cap rate is a percentage: NOI divided by value. Together they produce the value estimate in the income approach.
Why do cap rates change over time?
Cap rates move with interest rates, investor demand and the outlook for each property type and market. When borrowing costs rise, buyers generally need higher returns, so cap rates tend to rise and values fall unless income grows.
Need a value for a specific property?
An appraisal applies a market-supported cap rate to a carefully verified NOI. If you need a value for lending, an estate, a partnership or a tax appeal, request a free quote or call 800-511-4130. Most commercial appraisals cost $2,000 to $4,000; see our commercial appraisal cost guide.